Category Archives: Relational Logic – Critical Readings

Philippe Rahm-Form and function follow climate

evolution

evolution

Sustainable development!!!

Sustainable development as a term and practice has been a part of the colloquial diction of current day architecture. As righty quoted and explained in the passage sustainable development is “Development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.”  The theory that is explained in the introductory part of the passage is that the results of growing awareness and inclination towards sustainable development may be less visible, than in architecture, which is a byproduct of evolving digital technologies and new materials.

The concepts of sustainable development, described by the author as “space and energy management”, are the factors, which are politically, and socially critical, along with being architecturally important.

Form, Function, Climate!!

The recent history and development of architecture have been based on two very conflicting theories. The initiation of these theories started with the Louis Sullivan’s dictum of 19th century, in which his proposal, “form follows function”, challenged the decorative and symbolic practices of architecture. The idea of the proposal was to be rationalist and functionalist at the core and to be able to give form to functions that were predefined at various levels. The contradiction and challenge to this theory came from Louis Kahn in 1960 when he announced, “ function follows form”. The notion of this new theory was based on the realisations from the history that the functions and needs may change with time but the architectural forms will persist. The theorist hence concentrated on a new system of composition and design in which he treated architecture to be delinked from a functional program. The hierarchies of spaces hence created were in relation to each other, and although the built fabric was rigid, the functional usage would be flexible.

The author now talks about the concept that “function and form follows climate”, which he expresses to be the right direction of sustainable architecture in which the development, free of “formal and functional pre-determinations”. He wants to explore the scenario where in the architecture is completely deprogrammed and open to changes in weather conditions, seasons. He plans to replace the traditional approach to design and change the constraints, which are majorly functional and symbolic in nature, in order to achieve the freedom of use and interpretation.

4421794-3x2-940x627

“Place is to architecture, what meaning is to language”

The author puts forward an analogy, about the various cities and climatic regions. The lack of portable water of Venice for example, was the trigger behind the current day urban shape of the city. The squares of the city, the charming social places are all the result of the same necessity.

In the same vein, the presence of courtyard in the desert houses is the result of a requirement of an open space protected from dust storm. As explained about Baghdad, the spaces from cellar to roof have a variation in temperature and humidity, which allows the spaces to be used for various functions according to the time of the day and the season. On similar lines, the author gives us examples about the cool rooms, from the country houses of France.

The various examples imply to and highlight the manner in which the local architecture in terms of forms and functions have been a response to the local climate.

Independent Architecture!!!

Philippe Rahm in his conclusion talks about the capacity of architecture, as not being tied to a function, but being an independent interpretation which is not responding to the preconceived functional requirements. The talk of the passage was aimed to explain the readers that the way various modules and styles of architecture have developed over generations that have been a very efficient way of living for the locals of those regions, but the evolution of architecture over generations as a response to function and forms have taken a direction which is preconceived and which the author believes is not necessarily the efficient.

Talking of the response to climate and the way humans have adopted to the nature and climatic changes in various zones of the world, a connection to various topics of the assignment can be established, and noticed that the topic of this discussion can be slated as an example of environmental relationship.

Sustainability – Climate responsiveness?? Energy efficient??

The process of contemplation does result in many questions, which are unanswered.

When talking about Sustainable development, how do you strike a balance between the new age technologies, digital tools and the architecture, which has been developed and evolved over generations of acclimatization???

Is going back, the new going forward and developing???

How much should nature and architecture intervene with each other so that the results are optimized for both the sides???

 

“There is no point trying to close the windows and designing a sophisticated method of cooling the building, when all you have to do is open the windows”

                                                                                           - Working in the Region.

 

Also posted in Hriday Siddarth Saini, Relational Logic - Critical Readings | Comments closed

Saint Jerome “The dessert the study”

bubbletree

Saint Jerome “The dessert, the study” by Allison Smithson.
This reading is an analysis of the allegory of the two habitat of Saint Jerome that the renaissance painters painted in between 1400 and 1700 about Saint Jerome in spite he lived between 374 AD and 420AD.
In the dessert he is exposed to the nature, the desire to retreat from the urban place to be alone in the nature expressed a human desire for the freedom that seems to be in the nature.
In the Study he is no longer exposed but protected, with all the conveniences that a city offers, but in despite that, we can see in both paintings that they are reciprocal and have a pieces of each other, creating fragments of an enclave.
In the Grotto Saint Jerome still is in nature, but with the protection of a cave, merging the two ideas together.
What do we understand for sustainability? What is sustainability and how broadly it should be cast? Can it encompass economic, social and aesthetic concerns ever as it pursue environmental balance? Can architecture provide sustainable shelter and be art?
Architecture is cultural and social, as architects we must re-imagine architecture as a partner in the pursuit of a new relationship with nature. After all, architecture, it is shelter at its most basic human level.

Also posted in Relational Logic - Critical Readings, Sofia Kcomt Villacorta | Comments closed

Between the Desert and the Book!

 

 

 

1-s2.0-S0197397598000277-gr1                           woodcabin-ed01

 

 

In the text of (Saint Jerome , The desert .. the study ) , Alison Smithson showed a duality in approaching St.Jerome . A duality through the back and forth movement between environment and education , civilization and desert . Smithson discussed the pictures that was done in the renaissance that talked about the life of St. Jerome, and this illustration showed the importance of learning from the environment as a sociological fusion as well as elements in terms of harmony in nature . St.Jerome who traveled to explore has his pictures drawn in the era of exploration and the evolution , and in the renaissance years . Alison Smith showed the importance of the role of the Saint as his life is inspiring and how he lives a nude life and how this nudity leads to exploration and knowledge . Moreover , the text itself shows a continuous sequence about changes through out history and that currently we are going back to the idea of environment and fusion between sustainability , education , and society.

Overall View !

Since their presence on Earth, human being tried to adapt with the environment to maintain their survival. Materials, weather condition, food, location, protection … all were important elements to achieve this continuity. In this cycle architecture was an important theme in terms of developing this relationship between human and environment , exploring new concept like (inside, outside, shelter , individuality as well as gathering information and apply them to their current conditions . On the tributaries of Mesopotamia, people developed structures based from their available bamboo trees to form a shelter . There was were the idea of Iwan was developed and used in many places across Mesopotamia and Persia . Consuming environment in that time was a matter to construct and to survive , and within this stereotype architecture was evolved and developed (from a drawing to a building) and from a shelter to a village .Religion , Ethics , and spiritual thoughts was always in parallel with Architecture , not only in terms of constructing temples , churches , mosques and religious buildings  , but also in terms of how a life of priest , saint or a prophet influenced later on  architects and painters that always illustrated drawings about the coherence between saints and religion with environment and its resources . Saint Jerome (The Desert … The Study – Alison Smithson ) text about painting the life of St.Jerome reveals the importance of the civilization in studies as well as the importance of knowledge and exploration .

During the middle ages , architects , painters , and researches explored other continents and advanced their studies to integrate in in Architecture as well as other topics , yet these development lead to a fusion of industrial movement (industrial revolution ) that consumed most of the earth’s renewable and non renewable sources to integrate it with all kinds of daily life and non daily life products . Architecture as well had its switch after industrial Revolution and that was obvious in the art noveau as well as the communist movement and current contemporary designs. Contemporary architecture is towards more green . Green in terms of preserving nature, going back to the elements in nature , its considerable ideology that goes back and forth between early ages and current time .

In conclusion , availability of materials was then in the early ages a concern to spontaneous design , which means that people are obliged to use materials from where they live , but now and after all these revolutions and changes , architecture is going back to the idea of purism and self-sufficiency through eco-friendly approaches and how architects with their designs can integrate more the technology we achieved in an eco-futuristic approach .

 

by    Mohamad Yassin

Also posted in Mohamad Yassin, Relational Logic - Critical Readings | Comments closed

Form Follows Nature

The bubble house

The bubble house

 

Architecture, from modernity onwards, has ignored nature’s genius. Is it wrong, is it right? Many can debate this theme in terms of technological advancement that lets us overcome the issues brought by designing regardless of what surround us yet, in my opinion, nature has to be brought back.

As seen in class there are several ways to bring nature into architecture; positional, metaphorical, atmospherically, intangible, disturbed, and environmental. All of them valid yet, it depends on the depth and manner that this relationships are brought that matters. To shallow a relationship and becomes only decorative, too deep the relationship and the users comfort might be compromised.

Read More »

Also posted in Pablo Miguel Marcet Pokorny, Relational Logic - Critical Readings | Comments closed

Are we human?

Architecture-People-1-AA-Pavillion-20091

T1- The conditioned outdoor room

In order to unravel the main arguments demonstrated in the writing of Bernard Rudofsky, it is essential to understand author’s background and previous work. Rudofsky was most influential for organizing a series of controversial MOMA exhibits in the second half of the 20th century. Nowadays he is remembered for numerous urbane books that provide relevant design insight that is concealed in entertaining and subversive sarcasm. The text in its undertone could be related to his famous work in MOMA: Architecture without Architects, where he states that “Architectural History , as written and taught in the Western World , has never been concerned with more than a few select cultures. “. Read More »

Also posted in Agnieszka Wanda Janusz, Relational Logic - Critical Readings | Tagged , , , , | Comments closed